whistle-blo:/c/a/2008/02/29/BASUVBN0I.DTLArticle:Federal judge lifts
order against Wikileaks whistle-blo:/c/a/2008/02/29/BASUVBN0I.DTL
* Community
* Video
* Podcasts
* Photos
* RSS Feeds
* Newsletters
* Mobile
SFGate
======
Home of the San Francisco Chronicle
Home Delivery | Today's Paper | Ads
SFGateWeb Search by YAHOO!| Advanced Search
* Home
* News
* Sports
* Business
* Entertainment
* Food
* Living
* Travel
* Blogs
* Classifieds
* Jobs
* Homes
* Cars
* Close [X]Quick links to the best of SFGate | Still can't find it?
see Site Index
News »
Today
* Breaking News
* Today's Chronicle
* Traffic
* Weather
Sections
* life insurance Area & State
* Business
* Crime
* Education
* Environment
* Health & Medicine
* Nation
* Obituaries
* Opinion
* Politics
* Science
* Technology
* Weird News
cards playing custom World
Sports »
* 49ers
* Raiders
* Giants
* Athletics
* Warriors
* Sharks
More
* Blogs
* Chronicle Magazine
* Chronicle Watch
* Columnists
* Comics
* Earthquakes
* Live Views
* Lottery
* Maps
* Polls
* Public Notices
* Small Business
Features
Food »
* Bargain Bites
* Restaurant Reviews
cheap homeowners insurance Top 100 Restaurants
* Wine
Travel »
* Bay Area Traveler
* Reno & Tahoe
* Wine Country
Living »
* Gay & Lesbian
* Green
* Home & Garden
* Horoscope
independent clothing Outdoors
* SFiS
* Ski & Snow
* Style
*
Entertainment »
* 96 Hours
* Art
* Books
* Live Music
* Local Events
* Movie Showtimes
* Movies
* Theater Reviews
chinese teacher chicago learn mandarin chicago & Radio
Classifieds »
* Advertise With Us
* Cars
* Homes
* Jobs
* Merchandise
* Personals
* Pets
* Rentals
* [Redesign Feedback]
* Don't MissSFGreen
* Tales Of Leap Day
* Prince Would Die For U
* Chavvy Ready For Japan?
* Medium Rare, Not Medium Hair
San Francisco Chronicle
Federal judge lifts order against Wikileaks whistle-blower Web site
===================================================================
Bob Egelko, Chronicle Staff Writer
Friday, February 29, 2008
Printable VersionEmail This Article
delicious del.icio.us
digg Digg
technorati Technorati
reddit Reddit
facebook Facebook
slashdot Slashdot
fark Fark
newsvine Newsvine
google Google Bookmarks
Georgia (default) Verdana chinese lessons chicago New Roman Arial
(02-29) 17:35 PST SAN FRANCISCO -- A federal judge learn chinese chicago San Francisco
who had ordered the shutdown of a whistle-blowers' Web site where
private bank documents were posted changed his mind Friday, conceding
his original ruling might not have been constitutional.
U.S. District Judge Jeffrey White drew nationwide attention, and
widespread criticism from civil liberties groups and news
organizations, with his Feb. 15 injunction requiring a Bay Area
Internet registrar to disable the Wikileaks.org cheap auto insurance and prevent the
organization from transferring to another server.
Wikileaks describes itself independent clothes an enabler of "principled leaking" by
government and corporate insiders, who post documents on the site
anonymously. The injunction was requested by a Swiss bank, Julius Baer
& Co., whose documents, purporting to show tax fraud and
money-laundering by customers with funds in the Cayman Islands, were
displayed on the Web site.
The bank said the documents were stolen or forged and invaded its
customers' privacy.
The shutdown order was negotiated by the bank and Dynadot, the San
Mateo company that registered Wikileaks' use of the Web site. But the
American Civil Liberties Union, Public Citizen and a host of media
advocates and owners - including Hearst Corp., which owns The
Chronicle - called the injunction an unprecedented assault on streetwear clothes expression and likened it to closing a newspaper because of objections
to one article.
After a three-hour hearing Friday, White dissolved the injunction. He
also rejected the bank's request to extend a restraining order that
required Wikileaks and the custom playing cards registrar to remove the bank
documents from the Web site. The restraining order expired Friday.
Such decrees raise "serious questions of prior restraint (on speech)
and possible violations of the First Amendment," White said.
He also said federal courts may lack jurisdiction over the case
because the bank has failed to show that Wikileaks, or anyone
responsible for its operations, is based in the United States.
Even if other legal obstacles disappeared, White added, any injunction
against Internet posting is likely to be ineffective because the
documents are "fully out in the public domain" and can be transferred
to other sites.
The judge kept the bank's suit alive, but advised its lawyers to
"consider whether there may be other ways to achieve the same goals,"
such as suing for damages. The attorneys indicated afterward that they
would be willing to refile the suit in a state court if White
concluded federal courts have no jurisdiction.
White's ruling Friday implied volvo insurance judicial "abdication of authority over
the Internet," said William Briggs, a lawyer for Julius Baer. "That
means emo clothes a frontier that's wide open."
Ann Brick, an American Civil Liberties Union lawyer, homeowners insurance White
"understood the limits the First Amendment places on what courts can
do to deprive the public of the right to know." Steven Mayer, another
lawyer for civil-liberties groups, predicted the bank would encounter
the same free-speech problems in state court.
White made it clear he was aware of the unflattering media coverage of
his earlier ruling, and reflected on the difficulties courts face in
applying established legal doctrines to the Internet and to entities
like Wikileaks.
The organization says it was founded in 2006 by dissidents,
journalists and others from several nations. It has a Web server in
Sweden but no established headquarters and no president or formal
leadership structure, only an advisory board, according to its Web
poker cards Like the better-known Wikipedia, with which it is not formally
affiliated, it invites posters to submit, revise and comment on
documents on its site, and disclaims responsibility for the contents.
Despite White's Feb. 15 injunction, Wikileaks remained accessible
through its Internet Protocol or IP address, 88.80.13.160, and through
so-called mirror sites in Europe that replicate its contents.
On Friday, the owner of the Wikileaks.org domain name, John Shipman,
was represented in court by attorney Roger Myers. White told Myers he
considered Shipman to be Wikileaks' legal representative indie fashion asked if
he would object to an order that allowed the organization to regain
its domain name if it removed all information that identified
individual bank customers.
Myers replied that Shipman, an Australian citizen living in Kenya, has
no control over the Web site. Paul Levy, an attorney with Public
Citizen, said he doesn't believe a loose streetwear style of activists like
Wikileaks is even susceptible to a lawsuit.
As he announced his ruling, White observed that he was encountering "a
definite disconnect between the evolution of our constitutional
jurisprudence and modern technology."
E-mail Bob Egelko at begelko@sfchronicle.com.
jumbo playing cards VersionEmail This Article
delicious del.icio.us
digg Digg
technorati Technorati
reddit Reddit
facebook Facebook
slashdot Slashdot
fark Fark
newsvine Newsvine
playing cards Google Bookmarks
Comments
Subscribe to the San Francisco Chronicle Get The Chronicle for up to
40% off
1. Quaker teacher fired for changing loyalty oath
2. Man arrested for tossing acorns at S.F. Zoo rhino
3. Raiders make deal with ex-Giants safety Wilson; McCown, Porter
move on
4. Body of Top Model Katoucha Found
5. Charity director gets 10 days for soliciting sex from client
6. How to hate Barack Obama Right now, deep in the GOP dungeons,
they're...
7. Judge orders feds to try again on Bonds indictment
streetwear fashion How to hate Barack Obama Right now, deep in the GOP dungeons,
they're...
2. Quaker teacher fired for changing loyalty oath
3. Modern Gypsy sets record on Gold Rush voyage
4. Petaluma woman wins $80 million after buying first lottery ticket
5. The hidden 'ism'
6. The dog days of real estate
7. Matt Gonzalez joins Ralph Nader's ticket
* Hayward police release sketch of sex-assault suspect
* Stepfather accidentally runs over full color playing cards boy in San Jose
* Oakland man slain on late-night run to taco truck
* Trashing of cheap car insurance fire chief's home called 'symbolic gesture'
* Man arrested for tossing acorns at S.F. Zoo rhino
* Charity director gets 10 days for soliciting sex from client
* Bringing forests up to date
* Quaker teacher fired for changing loyalty oath
* Voracious moth customized playing cards in Sonoma County
* Federal judge ford insurance order against Wikileaks playing cards promotion Web
site
Bay Recruiter Top Jobs
RETAIL
Retail Asst Mgrs, PT chinese tutor chicago Stock+
CHICO'S
RETAIL
Now Hiring!
Linens N Things
SALES
Educational $600-$1200/week
streetwear clothing ACCOUNT EXECUTIVES Seccion Amarilla
DRIVER
Rev up your income.
FedEx
EDUCATION
Open until filled.
Hartnell College
Education
Full time 12 Month Academic Mgmt Pos
Ohlone College
Education
Butte College is a fully accredited..
Butte College
EDUCATION
A two-year college in Monterey...
Monterey Peninsula College
ENGINEER
Electrical Engineer: Req
ENGINEERS
EnergySolutions Job Fair - March
GOVERNMENT
$72,169.50 - $87,243 annually
Golden Gate Bridge, Highway & Transportation Distr
GOVERNMENT
(Airport Operations)
Port of Oakland
GOVERNMENT
$4536 - $5576 per month
Port of Oakland
HEALTHCARE
Value Analys. Spec Princip. Consult..
University HealthSystem Consortium
* About Top Jobs
* View All Top Jobs
auto insurance Search more Jobs
Yahoo! HotJobs
Advertisers
[Return to top]
* Home
* News
* Sports
* Business
* Entertainment
* Food
* Living
* Travel
* Blogs
* Classifieds
* Jobs
* Homes
* Cars
* Site Index
Advertising Services:
mandarin lessons chicago Place a Classified
* Advertise in Print
emo clothing Advertise Online
* Media Kit
* Today's Print Ads
bridge size playing cards promo playing cards * Home Delivery
* Subscribers
* Today's Paper
* RSS Feeds
* Newsletters
* Join Community
* Feedback
* Buy Photos
* FAQ
* Corrections
Company Info:
* Contact Us
* Hearst Corp.
* Privacy Policy
* Terms and Conditions
* Work for Us
* Chronicle in Education
* Events & Promotions
* Submissions
© 2008 Hearst Communications Inc.
Hearst playing cards promotional Be the first to share your thoughts on this story.Share your thoughts
on this story. - be the first to share your thoughts on this question.
- Sorry, comments are closed for this story.Federal judge lifts order
against Wikileaks whistle-blower Web siteBA